Homemade moon pie cookies recipe (2024)

FAQs

What are Moon Pie cookies made of? ›

MoonPies consist of a marshmallow filling sandwiched by two round graham cracker cookies, all coated in a thin layer of chocolate, vanilla, strawberry, or other flavored coatings. Costing only a nickel, they quickly become a popular treat.

A Moon Pie is an American snack, popular across much of the United States, which consists of two round Graham crackers, with marshmallow filling in the center, dipped in a flavored coating. The snack is often associated with the cuisine of the American South, where they are traditionally accompanied by an RC Cola.

Chocolate was the original and only flavor until the 1970s, when the bakery added banana. In the 1960s, the treat became so much more popular than any other treat they made that the bakery decided to exclusively make MoonPies.

Earl Mitchell invented the moon pie in 1919 when he worked for the Chattanooga Bakery.

3. What type of gelatin is used in a MoonPie? We use porkskin gelatin. 4.

They come in seven delicious flavors… chocolate, vanilla, banana, strawberry, lemon, orange, and caramel. Buy them individually or in boxes of twelve, and you can make your own variety box if you like. You'll need your own moonpies, plus another box to take back home with you to share.

If you aren't familiar with moonpies, then a wonderful treat awaits you. They are made in the Chattanooga Bakery, just a little bit down the road from our store, so the moonpies we offer are bakery fresh. They come in seven delicious flavors… chocolate, vanilla, banana, strawberry, lemon, orange, and caramel.

It all began in 1917 when a KY coal miner asked our traveling salesman for a snack “as big as the moon.” Earl Mitchell reported back and the bakery obliged with a tasty treat aptly named MoonPie. It was filling, fit in the lunch pail and the coal miners loved it. The rest, as they say, is history.

Whoopie Pie vs Moon Pie - Let's start by clearing up a common misperception: Whoopie Pies are not the same thing as a Moon Pie. A traditional moon pie has marshmallow filling sandwiched between graham cracker cookies, and then dipped in chocolate. Sounds good...but it's definitely not a Whoopie!

What drink goes with a MoonPie? ›

Sticking with tradition, if you're eating a MoonPie, you should be washing it down with an ice cold RC Cola. The South's most famous soft drink is Coca-Cola, which comes from Atlanta.

Inspired by the original MoonPie® cookies, this copycat version boasts tender, but slightly crisp graham cracker cookies flavored with the faintest bit of cinnamon, sandwiched around a sweet, chewy marshmallow filling, and dipped in a sweet chocolate glaze. Serve with ice cream or a glass of milk for dipping.

They are similar, but the cookie part of a Moon Pie is graham cracker-like, dark-ish in color, and it looks as though Wagon Wheels have something more like a light-colored sugar cookie. It also seems that Wagon Wheels can have a jam layer inside (along with the marshmallow), which a Moon Pie wouldn't.

Oddly enough, even though Chattanooga Bakery is stripping preservatives from its recipe, the shelf life of the product remains unchanged at 120 days. “That's the way the product naturally ages,” Johnston said. The chocolate encapsulating graham and marshmallow helps preserve the sandwich pie.

Mallomars vs Moon Pies

Mallomars are topped with marshmallow cream, then chocolate. Moon pies start with a larger graham cracker, then marshmallow cream, then another graham cracker, and then all of it encased in chocolate. So technically this recipe can be used to make either treat.

Mallomars vs Moon Pies

Layers create the main difference between gluten free mallomars and gluten free moon pies. Mallomars are topped with marshmallow cream, then chocolate. Moon pies start with a larger graham cracker, then marshmallow cream, then another graham cracker, and then all of it encased in chocolate.

Whoopie Pie vs Moon Pie - Let's start by clearing up a common misperception: Whoopie Pies are not the same thing as a Moon Pie. A traditional moon pie has marshmallow filling sandwiched between graham cracker cookies, and then dipped in chocolate. Sounds good...but it's definitely not a Whoopie!

There are normally five flavors of moonpies… chocolate, vanilla, banana, strawberry, and salted caramel. But once a year the Chattanooga Bakery does a batch of coconut minis for Mardi Gras, and lets the MoonPie General Stores order some for their customers.

It all began in 1917 when a KY coal miner asked our traveling salesman for a snack “as big as the moon.” Earl Mitchell reported back and the bakery obliged with a tasty treat aptly named MoonPie. It was filling, fit in the lunch pail and the coal miners loved it. The rest, as they say, is history.